Refuses to obey High Court Orders
Justice Samuel O. Taylor of the High Court in Sierra Leone continues to demonstrate his professionalism and commitment to upholding justice in the country’s judicial system. His recent handling of a case between Jaffar Zeghir and Leonoil Company has once again showcased his dedication to ensuring fairness and equity in the legal process.
In a recent ruling dated the 7th of February 2024, Justice Taylor delivered a judgment in favor of the Plaintiff, Jaffar Zeghir, in a matter involving a purchase of Two Hundred Thousand Litres of assorted fuel products from the Defendant, Leonoil Company Limited, to the tune of One Billion, Two Hundred and Ninety-Six Million, Four Hundred Thousand old Leones (Le1, 296, 400, 000). The judgment went in favor of the Plaintiff, and a stay of execution was granted by the Judge pending further proceedings.
However, Leonoil Company seems to be challenging the judgment as they have failed to comply with Justice Taylor’s order to pay the sum of Le 6,000,000,000 (six billion old Leones) into an interest-bearing account within 14 days from the date of the judgment. The company is now facing the risk of contempt of court if they do not comply with the court’s directive within the stipulated timeframe.
In response to the Judge’s ruling, Counsel for the Defendant/Applicant, Editayo Pabs-Garnon Esq, argued that his client is not opposed to providing the consignment of fuel to the Plaintiff. However, he raised concerns about the payment of taxes on the fuel, stating that the company should not be held responsible for taxes that are not their own but the responsibility of the National Revenue Authority (NRA). He expressed frustration that the NRA had only responded to their queries after the judgment had been delivered, causing confusion and delays in the process.
On the other hand, Counsel for the Respondent, Jacob Jibao Campbell Esq, presented a strong opposition to the application for a stay of execution, citing the Defendant/Applicant’s failure to take necessary actions and their attempts to deprive the Plaintiff of the benefits of the judgment. He argued that the Defendant/Applicant had been doing business with the 200,000 liters of fuel for three years, accruing profits and gains, and should not seek special circumstances to avoid paying taxes on the consignment.
In his ruling, Justice Taylor emphasized the importance of all parties respecting the legal process and complying with court orders. He expressed concern about the failure of institutions like the NRA to respond promptly to queries, leading to unnecessary delays and complications in legal proceedings. He urged all parties involved to adhere to the rule of law and ensure justice is served.
As the case between Jaffar Zeghir and Leonoil Company continues to unfold, it remains to be seen whether the oil company will comply with the court’s order or face further legal consequences. Justice Taylor’s unwavering commitment to upholding justice and fairness in the judiciary of Sierra Leone is evident in his handling of this complex case, setting a high standard for legal professionalism in the country.