Does Holding Power Accountable Amount to Regime Change?

By Mahmud Tim Kargbo

When a ruling-party spokesperson accuses journalists of working to overthrow the government, the question extends beyond political rhetoric: is holding power accountable now being portrayed as an attempt to change the regime? That question has emerged from the controversy involving SLPP National Publicity Secretary Moses Sellu Mambu, whose reported accusations have drawn journalists Thomas Dixon and Victor Jones, Liberty Online TV presenters Kadijah Bangura and Mabel Kabba, and Truth Media into a dispute over the legitimacy of independent journalism. Allegations of political conspiracy and descriptions of media organisations as regime change platforms risk turning legitimate scrutiny into a test of political loyalty. The distinction matters because journalists are not elected to preserve governments; they are expected to examine how governments exercise power. A government that confuses scrutiny with subversion misunderstands the very purpose of democratic accountability.

Journalists serve the truth, not regimes. Their responsibility is to investigate, question, inform and hold public authority accountable, irrespective of which political party occupies State House. They do not negotiate mining agreements, award procurement contracts, approve energy arrangements, negotiate sovereign loans, collect taxes or authorise public expenditure. Nor do they determine political appointments, distribute national wealth or decide how public institutions perform. When citizens demand a change of government through democratic means after examining its record, responsibility rests with the political choices that produced their dissatisfaction, not with the journalists who reported them. Truth is not treason.

The treatment of Kadijah Bangura and Mabel Kabba deserves particular attention. Journalists must be able to conduct political interviews, challenge official explanations and investigate uncomfortable questions without having their professional independence portrayed as evidence of partisan conspiracy. The accusations involving Liberty Online TV and Truth Media raise wider concerns about the ease with which political disagreement can become an attack on media credibility. Reporters Without Borders, in its assessment of Sierra Leone’s media environment, identifies the economic vulnerability of journalists and the potential for political interests to exploit financial and material dependence to influence coverage. Such conditions make editorial independence a democratic necessity, not a professional luxury. (https://rsf.org/en/country/sierra-leone)

Sierra Leone’s Constitution provides the democratic foundation for this responsibility. Section 11 of Chapter II recognises the media’s responsibility to highlight the Government’s accountability to the people, while Section 25 of Chapter III protects freedom of expression, including the right to receive and impart information. These provisions do not place journalists above professional standards or the law. They establish that questioning public authority is a legitimate component of constitutional government. A public officeholder may challenge inaccurate reporting, demand corrections and pursue lawful remedies, but cannot reasonably expect immunity from scrutiny. Public office carries an obligation to answer questions; it does not confer a right to silence those asking them. (https://www.parliament.gov.sl/constitution-of-sierra-leone.html)

The International Monetary Fund’s December 2025 Governance and Corruption Diagnostic provides an important institutional perspective. Its assessment identifies weaknesses in public procurement, limited enforcement of the rule of law and deficiencies in public financial management as factors contributing to inefficient resource allocation and diminished public confidence. The report also identifies approximately US$1.2 billion in extractive exports in 2023, compared with US$48 million in extractive sector revenue. Export value and government revenue are not interchangeable, but the disparity invites serious examination of mining agreements, fiscal arrangements and the country’s return from its mineral wealth. Journalists did not negotiate these agreements or determine their financial terms; investigating whether the public receives a fair share of its natural resources is precisely the kind of accountability their profession demands. (https://www.imf.org/en/publications/technical-assistance-reports/issues/2025/12/10/sierra-leone-technical-assistance-report-governance-and-corruption-diagnostic-572467)

Energy arrangements present another accountability question that cannot reasonably be transferred to the press. The IMF’s November 2024 Climate Policy Diagnostic identifies costly electricity purchasing arrangements, inadequate procurement transparency and financial weaknesses within Sierra Leone’s electricity sector. It discusses expensive take or pay agreements and financial losses associated with weaknesses in electricity distribution and procurement. These contractual decisions have consequences for public finances and the cost of electricity to consumers. Journalists did not negotiate the agreements, approve their financial obligations or determine the procurement procedures. Those who negotiate national energy contracts must explain their costs; those who investigate them must not be blamed for their consequences. (https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024105-print-pdf.pdf)

The same scrutiny should apply to major infrastructure and public expenditure. Questions surrounding the construction cost of the Julius Maada Bio International Conference Centre and the refurbishment and expansion of Lungi International Airport deserve examination through contracts, audited expenditure and independently verifiable project information. The United States International Development Finance Corporation’s published project assessment identifies a proposed US$150 million loan and total project financing of US$281.5 million for the airport project. Such financing should not automatically be characterised as wasteful, but its terms, obligations and development benefits deserve public examination. The responsibility for inflated contracts, poorly negotiated loans, political patronage, appointments that favour loyalty over competence and imprudent utilisation of public funds belongs to those exercising the relevant public authority. The power to commit national resources must carry an equal obligation to account for them. (https://www.dfc.gov/sites/default/files/media/documents/9000105360.pdf)

The consequences of institutional performance are ultimately experienced by ordinary households. The United Nations Development Programme’s Human Development Report 2025 places Sierra Leone at 185th in its global Human Development Index ranking, with a value of 0.467. The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals Data Portal records that 88.1 per cent of the population experienced moderate or severe food insecurity in 2024, while 25.3 per cent experienced undernourishment. These figures demand serious examination of healthcare provision, educational outcomes, employment opportunities, inequality and the distribution of national wealth. Journalists did not create inadequate medical facilities, poor educational outcomes, hunger or the economic pressures confronting struggling households. Their responsibility is to investigate the policies and institutional decisions that shape these conditions, not to carry the blame for them. (https://hdr.undp.org/content/human-development-report-2025; https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/dataportal/countryprofiles/SLE)

Taxation makes the institutional distinction even clearer. Journalists do not collect customs duties, administer tax exemptions, determine revenue targets or enforce compliance on behalf of the state. Those responsibilities belong to the revenue authorities and other institutions legally entrusted with collecting and managing public funds. Journalists can investigate whether powerful commercial interests receive preferential treatment, whether tax exemptions are justified and whether taxpayers receive services commensurate with their contributions. The same scrutiny applies to flamboyant political lifestyles, unequal access to national opportunities and the inefficient performance of democratic institutions. The public must be able to examine not only how its money is collected, but also how those entrusted with it choose to spend it.

Government support for the media must be judged by the same principle. State House Communications Director Myk Berewa reportedly defended more than Le6.8 billion in media subvention provided since 2018, describing its purpose as supporting media operations, advocacy and journalists’ safety rather than purchasing endorsements. The amount, its recipients and its disbursement deserve transparent public accounting. Government assistance can strengthen a financially vulnerable media sector, but it cannot create an obligation to defend the President, promote the ruling party or suppress uncomfortable findings. Public money may support journalism; it cannot purchase its conscience.

None of this exempts journalists from professional responsibility. They must verify allegations, distinguish fact from opinion, provide subjects with a fair opportunity to respond and correct demonstrable errors. Politicians who believe they have been misrepresented should challenge the evidence through lawful and professional channels rather than substitute accusations of conspiracy for substantive rebuttal. The press must answer for the accuracy of its reporting, just as public officials must answer for their decisions. Accountability is a reciprocal democratic obligation, not a privilege reserved for those outside government.

A journalist does not remove a government from office simply by reporting what has happened. Governments lose public confidence through their own decisions; citizens determine their political future through the ballot. The newsroom does not appoint governments, negotiate their contracts or spend their money. Its duty is to ensure that the public can see, question and judge the record. If that scrutiny makes those in power uncomfortable, the discomfort is not evidence of treason. It is evidence that democratic accountability is doing its work. Journalists serve the truth, not regimes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *